Quality and Operational Challenges in
Nepal’s WWTP Projects
FEATURED PAPER
By Yamanta Raj Niroula, PMP
and
Sampada Khadka
Kathmandu, Nepal
Abstract
Nepal has made substantial investments in wastewater treatment infrastructure over the past two decades, particularly through ADB-financed programmes. Yet only about 10 percent of households are connected to sewer networks, and an estimated 2-3 percent of urban wastewater receives effective treatment, well below the government’s 20 percent target. This paper examines six major WWTP projects in Nepal to investigate why quality and performance problems persist despite formal contractual, supervision, and QA/QC arrangements. The project record reveals a recurring pattern of delayed delivery across major contracts, contract termination and re-procurement in one major package, and documented post-handover operation and maintenance shortcomings at Guheshwori, a plant otherwise recognized for continuous operation. The analysis traces these outcomes across the project lifecycle, identifying recurring weaknesses in procurement capability assessment, interdisciplinary design and constructability review, construction quality control, commissioning, and operational handover. It argues that conventional project controls remain largely oriented toward demonstrating physical and contractual completion, while sustained treatment performance depends on integrated system operation under realistic loading and long-term operating conditions. The paper proposes a five-point quality governance framework comprising competency-based procurement, mandatory constructability and interdisciplinary design review, lifecycle QA/QC with independent verification, an independent commissioning and performance gate, and performance-based lifecycle accountability. The central proposition is that WWTP project success should be measured not by completion of the physical asset alone, but by its ability to deliver reliable treatment performance throughout operation.
Keywords: Wastewater Treatment Plants; Lifecycle Quality Management; Treatment Performance; Project Delivery; Constructability Review; QA/QC; Testing and Commissioning; Operation and Maintenance; Performance-Based Contracting; Nepal.
- Introduction
Wastewater Treatment Plants (WWTP) are judged against two distinct outcomes: whether the facility is completed and whether it performs reliably after completion. The first is relatively easy to document through project milestones, equipment installation, testing and, taking-over. The second requires the plant to consistently remove BOD, TSS, nutrients and pathogens to the required standards under the electricity supply, staffing, maintenance capacity and operating conditions that actually exist. Much of the contractual and QA/QC architecture used for WWTP projects is structured around demonstrating physical completion. Yet public health and receiving-water outcomes depend on sustained treatment performance.
This distinction matters because a WWTP is an integrated process. Its performance depends on the interaction of civil works, hydraulic design, mechanical and electrical equipment, instrumentation, process control, biological treatment, sludge handling, laboratory monitoring and operator capability (Jha & Bajracharya, 2014). A structural test or equipment inspection can confirm that an individual component meets its specification without establishing that the treatment process will function as intended. An undersized blower, poorly calibrated dissolved-oxygen probe, incomplete SCADA integration or incorrectly sized return-sludge system can affect biological treatment even when the associated civil works and pressure tests have been accepted. For this reason, WWTP quality ultimately has to be demonstrated at system level, under operating conditions and over time.
Nepal provides a useful setting in which to examine this completion-performance gap. The country has made sustained investments in wastewater infrastructure, particularly through the Kathmandu Valley Wastewater Management Project (KVWMP) and the Bagmati River Basin Improvement Project (BRBIP), including the use of Design-Build-Operate (DBO) contract model that is intended to connect contractor responsibility with longer-term plant performance (Karki, et al., 2024). Yet the 2021 national census reported household sewer connection at around 10 percent, while only an estimated 2 to 3 percent of urban wastewater generated in the country received effective treatment, against a government target of 20 percent by 2025 (National Statistics Office, 2021). The project record also includes plants affected by prolonged delay, termination and rebidding, interrupted commissioning and operational shortcomings. These outcomes may have different immediate causes, but their recurrence across projects warrants examination as a delivery-system problem that extends across procurement, design, construction, commissioning, and operation…
More…
To read entire paper, click here
How to cite this paper: Niroula, Y. R., and Khadka, S. (2026). Completion is not Performance: Quality and Operational Challenges in Nepal’s WWTP Projects; PM World Journal, Vol. XV, Issue X, October. Available online at https://pmworldjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/pmwj169-Oct2026-Niroula-Khadka-Completion-is-not-Performance.pdf
About the Authors

Yamanta Raj Niroula, PMP
Kathmandu, Nepal
![]()
Yamanta Raj Niroula is a senior project management professional with more than 20 years of experience in infrastructure development and project delivery across Asia, Africa, and the Middle East. His experience spans roads, electrical infrastructure, wastewater treatment plants, logistics facilities, and disaster recovery programmes, including assignments in complex geographic, institutional, and resource-constrained environments.
His work covers the full project life cycle, from planning and design through procurement, project controls, contract administration, construction, commissioning, and evaluation. He has served as Project Controls Specialist, Design Manager, Planning and Project Controls Manager, Engineer, and Project Manager with international organizations and United Nations agencies in Nepal, the Maldives, Singapore, Afghanistan, the Philippines, Bangladesh, Nigeria, Yemen, Sudan, and Ethiopia.
Throughout his career, Yamanta has worked with multidisciplinary teams and across complex contractual and institutional settings, coordinating clients, consultants, contractors, government institutions, and development partners. This experience has given him a practical understanding of the challenges that shape infrastructure delivery across different operational environments.
He holds a Bachelor of Engineering in Civil Engineering, a Master of Arts in Rural Development, and a Diploma in Civil Engineering. He is a certified Project Management Professional (PMP®) and has been a member of the Project Management Institute (PMI) since 2010.
Based in Kathmandu, Yamanta serves as an International Correspondent for PM World Journal. He can be contacted at niroulayr@gmail.com.
View his full correspondent profile at https://pmworldlibrary.net/yamanta-raj-niroula/.
To view other works by Yamanta Raj Niroula, visit his author showcase at https://pmworldlibrary.net/authors/yamanta-raj-niroula/

Sampada Khadka
Kathmandu, Nepal
![]()
Sampada Khadka is a Civil Engineer with experience in infrastructure development, construction quality management, and digital construction monitoring. She holds a Bachelor’s degree in Civil Engineering from Tribhuvan University and is a licensed engineer registered with the Nepal Engineering Council.
Her professional interests include water resources, wastewater management, sustainable infrastructure, construction quality, and project monitoring. Her field experience includes work on an ADB-funded Wastewater Treatment Plant project in Kathmandu, where she gained direct exposure to construction quality and operational issues relevant to the subject examined in this paper.
Sampada currently works as a Construction Analyst, focusing on the digital analysis of building construction projects. Her work involves examining project information to support workflow improvement, construction monitoring, and project management. This combination of site-based engineering experience and digital project analysis informs her interest in understanding how infrastructure projects perform in practice, particularly where construction quality and long-term operational requirements intersect.
Sampada lives in Kathmandu, Nepal and can be contacted at sampadakhadka682@gmail.com.








