From the Executive Editor’s Desk 3
EDITORIAL
By Dr. Miles Shepherd
Executive Editor
Salisbury, England, UK
Regular readers may recall that the purpose of these notes is to offer some basic advice for authors of papers submitted to PMWJ, particularly those who wish their work to be peer reviewed. The notes are aimed at those starting out on their writing career, rather than experienced authors. What I hope to do is make the process easier by explaining what we look for and how this helps ensure that readers actually read your work.
For many authors, myself included, the starting point for their article is a dissertation or some other form of academic writing. A dissertation has a well-known structure, and this framework should be the same for a journal article, whether or not the author wishes it to be peer reviewed.
Having said that, there are some distinct differences between a dissertation and a journal article. Their audiences are different and they serve different purposes. The major academic publishing houses often list these differences, and I have consulted one of the best known to compile the following list of differences.
The key point to remember is the audience. The PMWJ’s audience is eclectic, a mix of academics, students and practitioners. The principal aim of a dissertation is to show an understanding of research methods and literature, while a PMWJ article aims to make an original contribution to the field. A dissertation is typically longer, has more detail and is more in-depth. A PMWJ journal article is concise and focused on new findings or insights.
Authors of PMWJ peer review articles face a difficult set of issues when drafting their work as they need to be concise but say enough for the non-specialist reader to understand the problem, how it was addressed and what was found – all in about 20 pages! Structurally, the framework is very similar and follows the following sequence:
More…
To read entire article, click here
Note: From the Executive Editor’s Desk is a short monthly editorial for authors and potential authors by Dr. Miles Shepherd, PMWJ Executive Editor and Director of the PMWJ’s Peer Review program. Each article is a reminder of what to do or not to do when compiling or submitting a manuscript for publication. Dr. Shepherd’s author bio can be found at the end of this short article.
How to cite this work: Shepherd, M. (2026). Dissertations vs. Journal Articles, From the Executive Editor’s Desk; PM World Journal, Vol. XV, Issue X, October. Available online at https://pmworldjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/pmwj169-Oct2026-Shepherd-Dissertations-vs-Journal-Articles-Exec-Ed-Desk.pdf
About the Author

Dr. Miles Shepherd
Executive Editor, PMWJ
Salisbury, UK
![]()
Dr. Miles Shepherd is Executive Editor, Advisor and International Correspondent for the PM World Journal in the United Kingdom. He retired from a 30 year career in the British Army in 1994. He is also managing director for MS Projects Ltd, a consulting company supporting various UK and overseas Government agencies, nuclear industry organisations and other businesses. Miles has over 35 years’ experience on a variety of projects in UK, Eastern Europe and Russia. His PM experience includes defence, major IT projects, decommissioning of nuclear reactors, nuclear security, rail and business projects for the UK Government and EU. His consulting work has taken him to Japan, Taiwan, USA and Russia. Past Chair and Fellow of the Association for Project Management (APM), Miles is also past president and chair and a Fellow of the International Project Management Association (IPMA). He was, for seven years, a Director for PMI’s Global Accreditation Centre and is past Chair of the ISO committee developing new international standards for Project Management and for Program/Portfolio Management. He served on British Standards Institute project management committee (2002 – 2026) including 5 years as Chair. He was involved in setting up APM’s team developing guidelines for project management oversight and governance. Miles is based in Salisbury, England and can be contacted at miles.shepherd@msp-ltd.co.uk.
To see other works by Miles Shepherd, visit his author showcase in the PM World Library at https://pmworldlibrary.net/authors/miles-shepherd/








