SPONSORS

SPONSORS

An Open Challenge

 

Response to “Extending Earned Value

Management to Firm Fixed Price Contracts

Through a Multi-Perspective Analytical Framework

 for Mixed Contract Portfolios” by Dr. Rodriguez

 

LETTER TO THE EDITOR

By Dr. Paul D. Giammalvo

Jakarta, Indonesia

12 September, 2026


Dear David and Subscribers

In the August 2026 issue, you published an article entitled “Extending Earned Value Management to Firm Fixed Price Contracts Through a Multi-Perspective Analytical Framework for Mixed Contract Portfolios”, by Dr. Alexander Rodriguez with a foreword by Wayne Abba.[1]

With over 55 years of firsthand experience applying Earned Value Management to Firm Fixed Price and Unit Price In Place contracts, where our own money is on the line as both an OWNER and as a CONTRACTOR, I found several fundamental errors/omissions indicating a lack of a full and complete understanding of the complete history of earned value management, especially between how the private sector has been using Earned Value Management for at least 120 years for Firm Fixed or Unit In  Place Contracting methods.

Challenge #1- “Traditional” EVM was developed for environments in which the project owner has visibility into contractor actual costs

What Dr. Rodriguez calls “traditional” earned value totally ignores the fact that the underlying concepts of Earned Value Management date back to the Old Testament, as a “cash on delivery” or “payment for performance” concept.[2] And[3]. This renders his claim that Earned Value Management, as advocated by ANSI/SEA 748, is at best a grammatical distortion if not a misrepresentation.  Earned Value Management, at least under ANSI/SEA 748, is not TRADITIONAL, but in fact, is an ABERRATION or a DISTORTION of the fundamental concepts as documented by the research of Taylor, Gantt, Fayol, the Gilbreths et al., as captured and documented by Gillette and Dana in their 1909 book “Cost Keeping and Management Engineering: A Treatise for Engineers, Contractors and Superintendents Engaged in the Management of Engineering Construction”

The historical origins of Earned Value Management can be further validated by referencing Baihaqi and Ibn Majah, Hadith no. 2468, around 650 AD, where the Prophet Mohammed said: “Give the wages of the employee before his sweat dries.”[4]  This clearly validates that the CLASSIC or TRADITIONAL purpose of Earned Value Management was as a PAYMENT FOR PERFORMANCE scheme. Any combination or permutation that DIVORCES payment from performance is clearly a NON-TRADITIONAL application.

More…

To read entire Letter to the Editor, click here

How to cite this work: Giammalvo, P. D. (2026). An Open Challenge: Response to “Extending Earned Value Management to Firm Fixed Price Contracts Through a Multi-Perspective Analytical Framework for Mixed Contract Portfolios” by Dr. Rodriguez, PM World Journal. Vol. XV, Issue X, October. Available online at https://pmworldjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/pmwj169-Oct2026-Giammalvo-Open-Challenge-letter-to-editor.pdf

[1] Rodrigues, A. (2026). Extending Earned Value Management to Firm Fixed Price Contracts Through a Multi-Perspective Analytical Framework for Mixed Contract Portfolios; PM World Journal, Vol. XV, Issue VIII, August. https://pmworldjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/pmwj167-Aug2026-Rodrigues-Extending-EVM-to-Firm-Fixed-Price-Contracts-3.pdf
[2] Geneste, S. (2019). The True Origins of EVM: A historical approach to scheduling and incentive schemes, PM World Journal, Vol. VIII, Issue IX, October- https://pmworldlibrary.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/pmwj86-Oct2019-Geneste-the-true-origins-of-evm.pdf
[3] Bertille Hu- Hu. B. (2019). The History of Earned Value Management through Incentive Plans, PM World Journal, Vol. VIII, Issue VIII, September.- https://pmworldjournal.com/article/the-history-of-earned-value-management
[4] Maloni, A. M. CDT, PMP, (2010). PROJECT MANAGEMENT: EARNED VALUE AND PROMPT PAYMENT PRACTICES OBSERVED FROM VIEW OF ISLAMIC SHARIAH LAW